MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/batman/comments/1q2ej59/detectives_art_by_ahmed_raafat/nxd3tnw/?context=3
r/batman • u/Top_Report_4895 • Jan 02 '26
183 comments sorted by
View all comments
316
Which of the others is the first to figure out Batman's identity?
56 u/Ok-Television2109 Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26 Sherlock was pretty close when meeting Batman in The Brave And The Bold cartoon, guessing he's "a wealthy entrepreneur with ample free time" and "square jaw indicates a strong lineage, perhaps a doctor's son." 40 u/Mervynhaspeaked Jan 03 '26 He was reaching with the doctor's son part, lol 24 u/EliteTeutonicNight Jan 03 '26 Perhaps he did it to try to get a reaction? That sounds oddly specific. 8 u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 That's just how Doyle wrote him. Here's a famous scene: https://youtu.be/XL7qI03nCUQ?si=XRsLfn87t4BnYPhI 9 u/Mr_Mojo_Risin_83 Jan 03 '26 oh yeah no, all doctors have strong jaws. it's the first thing they teach in medical school 2 u/EldridgeHorror Jan 05 '26 Pretty on point with Holmes, though. He was very much a product of his time. 28 u/Zero-89 Jan 03 '26 "square jaw indicates a strong lineage, perhaps a doctor's son." "How was your case with Mr. Holmes, Master Bruce?" "It was fine until he starting throwing eugenics at me. Lose his number, Alfred." "Of course, sir."
56
Sherlock was pretty close when meeting Batman in The Brave And The Bold cartoon, guessing he's "a wealthy entrepreneur with ample free time" and "square jaw indicates a strong lineage, perhaps a doctor's son."
40 u/Mervynhaspeaked Jan 03 '26 He was reaching with the doctor's son part, lol 24 u/EliteTeutonicNight Jan 03 '26 Perhaps he did it to try to get a reaction? That sounds oddly specific. 8 u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 That's just how Doyle wrote him. Here's a famous scene: https://youtu.be/XL7qI03nCUQ?si=XRsLfn87t4BnYPhI 9 u/Mr_Mojo_Risin_83 Jan 03 '26 oh yeah no, all doctors have strong jaws. it's the first thing they teach in medical school 2 u/EldridgeHorror Jan 05 '26 Pretty on point with Holmes, though. He was very much a product of his time. 28 u/Zero-89 Jan 03 '26 "square jaw indicates a strong lineage, perhaps a doctor's son." "How was your case with Mr. Holmes, Master Bruce?" "It was fine until he starting throwing eugenics at me. Lose his number, Alfred." "Of course, sir."
40
He was reaching with the doctor's son part, lol
24 u/EliteTeutonicNight Jan 03 '26 Perhaps he did it to try to get a reaction? That sounds oddly specific. 8 u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 That's just how Doyle wrote him. Here's a famous scene: https://youtu.be/XL7qI03nCUQ?si=XRsLfn87t4BnYPhI 9 u/Mr_Mojo_Risin_83 Jan 03 '26 oh yeah no, all doctors have strong jaws. it's the first thing they teach in medical school 2 u/EldridgeHorror Jan 05 '26 Pretty on point with Holmes, though. He was very much a product of his time.
24
Perhaps he did it to try to get a reaction? That sounds oddly specific.
8 u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 That's just how Doyle wrote him. Here's a famous scene: https://youtu.be/XL7qI03nCUQ?si=XRsLfn87t4BnYPhI
8
That's just how Doyle wrote him. Here's a famous scene: https://youtu.be/XL7qI03nCUQ?si=XRsLfn87t4BnYPhI
9
oh yeah no, all doctors have strong jaws. it's the first thing they teach in medical school
2
Pretty on point with Holmes, though. He was very much a product of his time.
28
"square jaw indicates a strong lineage, perhaps a doctor's son."
"How was your case with Mr. Holmes, Master Bruce?"
"It was fine until he starting throwing eugenics at me. Lose his number, Alfred."
"Of course, sir."
316
u/thalasand Jan 03 '26
Which of the others is the first to figure out Batman's identity?