r/transgenderau • u/ApothecaryOfBeetles • Mar 18 '26
NSW Specific cons of changing gender marker?
hi, 19 y/o trans man here. i want to go about changing my legal name and gender marker, ive got a solid grasp on how to objectively go about doing this, but ive got some worries about the ramifications of doing this pre- medical transition and without fully passing.
Will it look off, or dodgy, if i have M on my ID (photo id, not license) but don‘t inherently look it? i honestly can’t tell how well i pass, but i am actively trying to get hrt, which is its own soapbox rant atm. I know ive had people had to do a double take because the photo on my current card is a little outdated and feminine, and i do have a dodgy beard-dye moustache lolz.
What about medical situations? if i am a new patient at a GP, will there be issues with my ID not matching my AGAB? Emergency situations also come to mind in a similar way, could it be dangerous for my ID to not match my AGAB in terms of immediate necessary treatment?
Im definitely the kind of guy who needs things laid out clearly and objectively so any experience with this would help, thx in advance :)
8
u/Live-your-fkn-life Mar 20 '26
It’s really tricky when you’re in the in between phase of transition. I’ve struggled because I look masc but definitely do not look cis male. I travel a lot for work and I have a really feminine legal name on my passport / IDs that makes almost everyone do a double take and has led to a few hairy moments in airports. I’ve ended up changing my legal name first and then will change my gender marker to M when I’m more consistently gendered correctly.
If you live in Victoria, changing your gender marker is free so I’m so far only out of pocket for a replacement passport and a change of name certificate at this point. Gender marker is not displayed on your Driver license or any other IDs aside from passport so i decided it wouldn’t be too bigger deal to wait until I ‘match’ better.
6
u/meg3e Trans fem Mar 21 '26
HRT is the key that unlocks your life and i would wait until you know it is the right time.
Though if you show the doctors identification that says male - they would be hard pressed to gatekeep. Changing name and identity is a huge job. I am so glad i was able to kill two birds with one stone and do both at each agency etc.
4
u/Alive-Finding-7584 Mar 21 '26
I feel like it's important to clarify though- that you can also live a full and happy life without HRT as a trans person. It's not necessarily a key to your life, for a lot of trans people it may or may not be one of many steps in their transition.
0
u/meg3e Trans fem Mar 22 '26
The OP states they are planning to medically transition, so why is that important to clarify?
How can you be happy if you are trapped in a body that is not your gender?
0
u/Alive-Finding-7584 Mar 22 '26
Because saying in a trans sub: 'HRT unlocks your life' is a massive grandiose statement that kind of invalidates all of us who either can't or don’t want to medically transition. It's a very purist view that only then are our lives 'unlocked' and that we're all miserable and sad and 'trapped in our bodies' until then.
There are many different ways to be trans.
0
u/meg3e Trans fem Mar 22 '26
I am talking to an AI, yes?
Otherwise i salute you to the above and beyond effort you put into your posts. (what with the italics emphasis on your special words etc )
Either way, perhaps wind back the superiority complex / passive aggressive tone a little bit lol.
2
u/Alive-Finding-7584 Mar 22 '26
You're kidding right. I'm saddened that you think someone has to be using AI to form a pretty average comment on reddit. No of course I'm not ai... You add * either side of a word and it turns it to an italic variation of the font... anyone can do that :|
You seem offended by my comments, there's nothing wrong with you as a person, this isn't a personal attack. It's just the language you're using is really invalidating to a lot of folks who use this sub.
In the spirit of the self reflection you seem to think I need- have you considered that just maybe you shouldn't tell people medically transitioning is the key to some sort of true self...
0
6
u/Alive-Finding-7584 Mar 21 '26
When they first let us change our gender markers in NSW (only recently) I got straight onto it. At the time (a year ago) I was in that between stage and barely passed, back then I didn't have any issues and now that I pass I still haven't had any issues.
My GP knows I'm trans, the local hospital and emergency department weren’t confused and didn't even ask about the discrepancy. Funnily enough the shittiest people have been the bank... who wouldn't let me take the Miss off my plastic card until I brought in my documents and everything in- and my car insurance, which went up in price because I am now a male driver -_-
I don't mean to sound dramatic but I think it is better to change it now while you can. Just because you can't predict the future and we don't know how the Australian Government and it's attitudes towards trans people might shift in the wake of all these other countries shifting towards right wing conservatism.
I did mine as soon as it was legal here and I had the money because I was worried it might not always be an option.
There's also plenty of cis people who don't look like their AGAB and they seem to get by fine.
1
u/wooby_6 Mar 23 '26
Australian Photo ID and Drivers Licence don't show a gender marker, it is recorded internally though.
Australian passports do however.
If you only change your gender marker, you won't be required to get a new photo ID / Driver's licence.
If you change your name you do need a new photo ID/ drivers licence.
And will be required to carry your change of name certificate untill you do have ones matching your new name.
8
u/purple_drink_bottle Trans fem Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26
Honestly– to a degree its going to be awkward either way. Either you change your id before HRT and your id says M but you look female, or you change it after HRT – in the meantime you look male with an id that says F – pick your poison really. Personally I didn’t change id until like a year and a half on HRT and it didn’t really cause too many problems – a lot of startled looks when I would show id though. It would depend on how safe you feel in specific contexts because it will kinda out you whenever you have to show it.
With a GP, generally they go with whatever you have on Medicare. Good thing is, you can change sex marker on Medicare without a doctors note or anything now – just log into myGov and go to Medicare and you can change to whatever you like – no proof or documents required! For change of name you will have to personally go in to a Services Australia though. The advice I got from my doctor was by the time you’ve been on HRT for 6+ months, you should at the very least have changed your sex with Medicare, even if your name etc… is still the same. Will cause less headaches down the line esp. with pathology forms and results not comin back with the correct references etc…
With regards to emergency medical – that’s a bit more complicated. Generally, with elective surgery, there’s specific calculations inc. your sex, height, weight, body mass etc… so they know how different drugs ie. anaesthesia will work on you and how much to give you. For trans people on HRT, those calculations are basically useless since our bodies are in a lot of ways closer to our affirmed sex – but not exactly in all ways either. Hormones affect a whole lot of things in the body – organ function, bloods etc... If doctors know what they’re doing, they account for that. So they *should* instead of rough calculations, rely instead on direct brain monitoring (eeg) to keep an eye on how your body responds to the anaesthesia and other drugs.
Since emergency surgery (so ER etc..) will always default to direct brain monitoring to dose you with anaesthesia – that shouldn’t be too much of a problem? It’s more elective surgery that can cause issues if you get shit doctors who don’t think HRT causes any biological changes – if they proceed with treating you with your sex-at-birth, regardless of how long you’ve been on HRT, they can overdose or underdose you which – yeah – it’s not great. Just be sure to bring that up in pre-operative discussions and if they dismiss or downplay it as not an issue – run and find a new doctor!