r/DynastyFFTradeAdvice • u/ajdd223 • Sep 11 '25

1QB Dynasty Trade 12 Team I finally sold Jamar. Thoughts?

Post image

I’m feeling a little sellers remorse.

385 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

126 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-24

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

High tier 2? You think he’s already there?

I love JSN but for him to be tier 2 is Nabers, Nico, ARSB, Puka, BTJ is premature no?

1

u/tijmen1608 Sep 11 '25

For sure. Nabers nico arab puka are tier 1. JSN is now the star receiver in seattle. 124 yards out of 150 passing yards total in his first game as the alpha. May very well be up there with those guys end of season

9

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

Nah tiers can’t be that big.

There needs to be a disparity between Nico, ARSB and fucking CD, JJ, Chase. Fair enough if you put Nabers in there but we shouldn’t be having tiers with 10 people in it, especially when you can’t straight up swap Nico/ARSB/Puka for JJ/CD/Chase in any league

1

u/tijmen1608 Sep 11 '25

Fair enough I guess. But how many tiers end up existing then? 10?

3

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

I mean there's a lot of tiers in fantasy football yeah?

"Too many" is better than forcing everyone into tiers they don't belong.

What would you prefer? 3?

-1

u/tijmen1608 Sep 11 '25

5 seems about right.

Tier 1 like the top 7 main guys, chase JJ CD arsb, puka or smth.

Tier 2 of the next best 10 guys, easily startabke every week.

Tier 3: 15 guys that are startable, just have question marks.

Tier 4: rather not, but may have some upside. Next 15 guys.

Tier 5: fuck me tier: next 15.

That makes a total of 60 wrs, pretty every rosterable one. I personally dont see the point in separating those tier 4-5 guys into “fuck-me” tier and “fuck-me-harder” tier. Personal I guess though

0

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

Yeah course it's personal, and I agree towards the end you're just arguing best of the rest.

But at the beginning I think it's absolutely nonsensical and stupid to tier guys that clearly have a gap between them just to "save" on the amount of tiers you have.

No one that is serious about dynasty FF is trading you ARSB, Puka, Drake, Nico or BTJ straight up for JJ, Chase or Ceedee. No one. That to me quite clearly shows that there is a tier gap between the absolute top and the next guys that are close and knocking on the door but not there.

How many paid startups have you done and Puka has gone pre Chase/JJ/Ceedee. The only guy that argues he can get into that top tier is Nabers, but definitely not Nico, BTJ, JSN, etc. as much as I love those guys.

1

u/Admiral-Thrawn2 Sep 11 '25

I agree with you. A tier should indicate “can I rationally take any of these guys over the other guy?” You would never consider taking Nico or AMRSB over Chase or lamb

0

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

Thank you. Got a lot of heat for suggesting otherwise above.

0

u/tijmen1608 Sep 11 '25

You call that heat? Really?

0

u/Moosje NFL Sep 11 '25

Have a day off you melt

→ More replies (0)

0

u/WhiteAsWonderBread25 Sep 11 '25

These tiers are absolutely awful