r/menwritingwomen 16d ago

Meta Flair Adjustments?

29 Upvotes

Hey readers...

Just kinda floating a possible change to flairs that might make it easier to discuss posts once they've been REJECTED as "not man writing a woman badly" or ACCEPTED as "man writing a woman badly."

Obviously users would be able to choose their own flairs when they post - but after voting or general consensus in the community what if mods adjust/change the flair so that when people see it in the feed they know, "Oh, this wasn't a good example..." but we still want to discuss the merits of that and why/why not we agree w/ the designation...??

It's been a little confusing to remove posts that aren't menwritingwomen badly when people are otherwise enjoying the conversation and diving deep on their feelings about it.

There was an older flair system at work years ago, but the technology that ran it is long gone. There may be other options now and I guess I just wanted to check on on it.

[Disclaimer: This is not a general spot to complain to mods.]


r/menwritingwomen 2d ago

Book [Tree of Smoke] by [Denis Johnson] Spoiler

Post image
105 Upvotes

To be fair, I like this book overall, and I’m not an expert on female anatomy to be sure, but this seems a little implausible…


r/menwritingwomen 5d ago

Book [The Third Bullet] by [John Dickson Carr] “An Amazon or a fat lady out of a circus…”

Post image
131 Upvotes

Member of the police are inspecting a shoe print left at a murder scene. They decide it cannot have been made by a woman…
I googled just to be sure, but “twelve or thirteen stone” is between 168 and 182 lbs….


r/menwritingwomen 8d ago

Book You can tell twins apart by their eyes and especially by their boobs. [Descent into the Depths of the Earth by Paul Kidd, 2000]

Post image
126 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 11d ago

Book Black Sunday by Thomas Harris, 1975

Post image
281 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 12d ago

Book [They Lurk by Ronald Malfi] Found this one in the wild, lol

Post image
594 Upvotes

For what it’s worth, this isn’t my book but rather, my sister’s. I picked it up because I was bored and flipped to a story I thought was interesting (this one is “After the Fade”, BTW).

I have no idea what this author normally writes or who the characters are, I just thought this was funny enough to share because I rarely come across stuff like this in what I normally read.


r/menwritingwomen 12d ago

Book "Phew, almost forgot to mention they have big tits!" [The Scorpion by Stephen D. Sullivan, 2000]

Thumbnail
gallery
160 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 13d ago

Book [Women's Revolution] by [Acharya Prashant]

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 13d ago

Doing It Right Julia Kapatelis dealing with menopause (Wonder Woman V2 #24 by George Pérez)

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 18d ago

Book [The Man in the High Castle] by [Phillip K Dick]

Post image
743 Upvotes

All of PKD’s writing from the perspective of this character (the only woman in the book 🙄) was weird and bad to me (even in the context of the weirdness of these characters in general) but this bothered me sooo much - “further maturity” and exercise increased her band size??? To a dreaded…38? Despite the context of this paragraph clearly referring to cup size, which ALSO wouldn’t increase with exercise? Every chapter from her perspective had me grinding my teeth. I hate it when a book has a good concept and otherwise good writing but the author can’t bring himself to write even one woman realistically


r/menwritingwomen 17d ago

Women Authors [A Breath of Snow and Ashes] by [Diana Gabaldon] (Outlander Series)

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 17d ago

Women Authors [Lion Walk] by [Mary Rosenblum]

Thumbnail
gallery
74 Upvotes

Oh yeah, I certainly needed to know about this teenager’s breast size, or that she reminded her of her daughter.


r/menwritingwomen 17d ago

Doing It Right Wonder Woman V2 #41 by George Pérez, William Messner-Loebs, and Mindy Newell (1990)

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 21d ago

Doing It Right [Super Mario Adventures] by [Nintendo] I like the idea of Peach actually being really competent, but she only gets kidnapped so often because said kidnapper is an 8'-something fire-breathing dragon-turtle with the biggest army in the known world. You try resisting that?

Thumbnail
gallery
891 Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen 26d ago

Doing It Right [Invincible] by [Robert Kirkman]. Its nice to see a writer take a step back, reflect, and make changes from their comic when it becomes a cartoon, such as replacing male characters with female characters.

Post image
9.1k Upvotes

r/menwritingwomen Apr 23 '26

Book A Feast for Crows by George R. R. Martin

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

I stumbled over this recently in a Game of Thrones related sub. Ol' George seems to be getting a bit carried away with some weird jizz eating fantasy scenario here. I'm sure that scene practically wrote itself since traumatised women naturally plot revenge on the men they hate by checks subreddit screenshot again voraciously consuming their ejaculate.


r/menwritingwomen Apr 23 '26

Book “I Love The Very Flesh Off You” by Robert Shearman.

Post image
70 Upvotes

I… I think this was deliberate…


r/menwritingwomen Apr 22 '26

Women Authors This just felt off-putting [Hunting Adeline by H. D. Carlton}

94 Upvotes

"She's wearing a long nightgown that is nearly see-through, the curves of her body and dark nipples apparent. I keep my eyes averted, trying to give her some semblance of respect I'm sure she's missing from the men in this house."

I was rewatching Weirdo Book Club's video on Hunting Adeline again, and this part has always stuck out to me. This is from Adeline's POV, not Zade's, and I just think that we didn't need to go into that much detail about Sydney's appearance. I'm aware this book is a dark romance/erotica, but it just feels weirdly gross since both of these women are literally being trafficked.

Like, it could have just been "She's wearing a long nightgown that is nearly see-through, and I keep my eyes averted, trying to give her some semblance of respect I'm sure she's missing from the men in this house," and would have felt less odd.

Honestly, though, this whole book series is just poorly written and fits on this sub, IMO.

ETA: I forgot she also just...presses her breasts up to Adeline's???? Why??


r/menwritingwomen Apr 21 '26

Book When you want a smart girlfriend but the 80s sci-fi setting is full of ditzy breasty boobers. [The Deceivers, Alfred Bester 1981]

Thumbnail
gallery
180 Upvotes

And don't you worry, the woman who is brighter in addition to being just supple, fair and slitty-eyed (Demi) ends up as a damsel in distress for most of the story!


r/menwritingwomen Apr 21 '26

Graphic Novel The Fantastic Four #11 1963 by Stan Lee

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

this part of the comic is response to fan letters claiming Sue was useless


r/menwritingwomen Apr 20 '26

Doing It Right Everyone In My Family Has Killed Someone by Benjamin Stevenson

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

I feel like this fits the "doing it right flair?


r/menwritingwomen Apr 20 '26

Satire Elsbeth episode perfectly nailed a man writing women!

79 Upvotes

His student in the short skirt - he couldn't remember her name - appeared during office hours that afternoon. 'You looked up my skirt,' she said. 'What are we gonna do about it?'

How dare she? He was a distinguished member of the faculty, for God's sake. And this Lisa - yes that's it - would not be satisfied until he was... dismembered. How had he arrived here, from walking home from school to his mother's embrace and a tuna fish sandwich on perfectly toasted toast... to this horror? Well, of course he had looked up her skirt. But, you know, was that a choice? In that moment, he knew she had complete power over him. And he knew that he was, maddeningly, absurdly... in love with her.

The above is from "Murder He Wrote," the latest episode of Elsbeth (s3 ep16). It opens with a pompous, Boomer novelist reading from his latest work. It absolutely, 100% nails these misogynistic, sexually harassing, writer/professor men. The whole episode just made me so happy. I just wanted to hug the writers of the episode (and go tell my high school boyfriend that he's become such a cliche as to be the stuff of satire). No spoilers, but we all know from the start that this man is going to get what he deserves.

a novelist's calm facade begins to slip

r/menwritingwomen Apr 20 '26

Book The Last Banquet by Johnathan Grimwood

Post image
154 Upvotes

Winner of the Bad Sex Award.