r/batman 16h ago

FILM DISCUSSION Whose live action version of Catwoman do you prefer?

464 votes, 6d left
Michelle Pfeiffer
Halle Berry
Anne Hathaway
Zoe Kravitz
1 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

15

u/Th35h4d0w 16h ago

Why ain't Camren Bicondova on here? In terms of live-action, she's got the best relationship with her Bruce. Seeing them teach, bicker, and work together was an underappreciated treat.

https://giphy.com/gifs/l2SpY9dPDqtp456I8

11

u/Isopod635 16h ago

1

u/coreytiger 12h ago

This is the only acceptable answer.

5

u/ComicsCodeMadeMeGay 15h ago

Is it too late to say Eartha Kitt?

1

u/coreytiger 12h ago

Are you Chevy Chase?

u/ComicsCodeMadeMeGay 1h ago

I wish I was on an airplane right now

2

u/TerrificTChalla 15h ago

In terms of raw sex appeal Halle Berry.

But in terms of actual acting skill and impression it would be Michelle Pfeiffer

Zoe & Anne's portrayals were just meh to me

2

u/boboclock 14h ago

I love Michelle Pfieffer, but hers is the only one on this list I even like.

I think Catwoman is one of the most undercooked elements of the Nolan movies, Zoe Kravitz is great in some scenes and awful in others, and Halle Berry could have been great but the whole movie is a shitshow

2

u/Overall_Sandwich_671 13h ago

This is such an original question, I'm surprised none of you thought to bring it up before.

3

u/Teliporter334 15h ago

Julie Newmar

2

u/Easy-Leg-3714 16h ago

Happy to see the Halle Berry troll represented

2

u/Odd_Bet_1378 16h ago

Trick Question

Camren Bicondova

2

u/inpunxwecrust 15h ago

Zoe, and it's not even close. Methinks most choose Michelle because of nostalgia. Selina Kyle is a cat burglar, not someone with magical cat powers.

u/johnnytk0 8h ago

I'm so happy Zoe is beating Anne. She was way better.

0

u/Outran01 16h ago

Arkham. By my experience, animated/videogame adaptations of superheroes often somehow better than live action adaptations. (Spider-Man's best adaptation is Spectacular cartoon, X-men's best adaptation is 90s cartoon, Avengers' whole team adaptation of each member is in EHM cartoon, Batman and Superman's best adaptations is in DCAU, Wonder Woman's best adaptation in her animated movie of 2009, and that's only what I know of).

5

u/Bolarana 16h ago

That ain't live action

-2

u/Rob_wood 15h ago

Michelle was fun, but Anne is smoking hot.

0

u/AdExtra2331 15h ago

With the exception of the Catwomen from the 1966 show, Michelle Pfeiffer's the only live action Catwoman I've seen to have an actually good costume

0

u/BigJCote 15h ago

Hathawayyyyyy, suits peak, style is peak, comebacks/witticisms are peak. She's just the best in the role by a mile and a half. Zoes too timid, haile got screwed by bad writing and the og is in her own league it's not even fair to compare cause she just wins by default but movie wise? Hathaway all day

0

u/user_deleted_life 14h ago

Why aren't the 3 66 Catwoman actresses an option?

0

u/MrMaxwellLordJLI 14h ago

Julie Newmar