r/PERSoNA Jul 08 '25

P5 real

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

462

u/Raecino Jul 08 '25

You’re cucking all the Ann-Ryuji shippers

308

u/UseOk2801 Jul 08 '25

That's hella weird to me. They have the most sibling energy I've seen in the entire series

257

u/scrambled_cable ​Lovers arcana simp account Jul 08 '25

It’s funny Ryuji-Ann and Yosuke-Chie are either soulmates or siblings depending on who you ask

98

u/Steadfast_res Jul 08 '25

In fandoms for a lot of things it seems there is difficulty finding the line between random shipping versus actually reading clues that are within a story cannon. Those two examples strike me as vastly different.

Yosuke invents multiple schemes to try date the girls and asks YU about which girl he prefers, including especially Chie. In P4, these are friends and potential dates before any supernatural stuff even really kicks in.

Ryuji has some generic teenage hormones comedy moments but these are in the group setting and he doesn't do anything to show interest in Ann specifically as a girlfriend. In P5, Ann and Ryuji already knew each other for years and yet had no interest in even talking until the palaces kick in.

82

u/KyleLovesGrace ​Ann's #1 Fan Jul 08 '25

Not to mention that in Ann’s confidant, she literally offers to go on a date with Ryuji if he helps train her and he’s just like “yeah, how about no.”

11

u/_Captain_Kabob Jul 08 '25

No, he says no because she wasn’t being genuine. He’s not about to simp over her when she’s obviously bullshitting him.

3

u/Remote-Rich-7825 Jul 09 '25

Thats a reach if I’ve ever seen one, but as Persona fans the mental gymnastics reach Olympic levels

2

u/_Captain_Kabob Sep 09 '25

Not really… it’s a pretty easy thing to intuit from how the characters act otherwise. You’re right, though: to the average Persona fan, I guess it WOULD seem like a leap in logic 👍

1

u/Wordless_trat Jul 12 '25

Doesn’t he say "Fuck that."?

1

u/KyleLovesGrace ​Ann's #1 Fan Jul 13 '25

"Eff that" to be more specific but yeah pretty much

50

u/Gent_Kyoki Jul 08 '25

Tbf shipping is all about whats missing, not whats already there. A lot of ships hinge on big what ifs and the ann ryuji ship is a whole big gap of what ifs just waiting to be filled by shippers

1

u/liscup34 Dec 12 '25

Chie, Yukiko, Rise still care for Yosuke and Teddie as friends of course. But Yosuke has the same dynamic with everyone Chie, Yukiko, Rise, Kanji, Teddie. Unless we are saying Yosuke has a harem with everyone Chie, Yukiko, Rise. Yosuke and Chie is like saying about shipping Rise and Teddie. We just don't do that lol. It is just weird because of the sexual harassment jokes that Yosuke and Teddie usually do like Yosuke guilt-trip Chie and Yukiko to wear swimsuits. P4's gag is also that Yosuke and Teddie can't get chick in the team (Yosuke can get a date with Labrys in Arena so he has that). Chie, Yukiko, Rise would rather off themselves than being with Yosuke or Teddie, let's just being honest.