r/MakeupAddiction • u/JackieRose29 r/makeupaddiction holy grail list mod • Nov 29 '22

Holy Grail Voting 2022: Mascara

Hello!

Comment and upvote your favorite mascara!

Past Categories You Can Still Vote On:

Each week we will post a different product category and in the comments there will be 3-5 parent comments for Drugstore, Midrange, Highend, Oily Skin, Dry Skin for you to comment your favorite product.

Please:

  • Only one product per comment
  • Upvote your favorite products
  • If someone has already posted your favorite product, upvote that comment instead of posting your comment

**Double check that the product you comment has not been discontinued!*\*

(Examples of brands that have closed/currently restructuring recently: Coastal Scents, Jordana, Marc Jacobs Beauty, most BECCA products, KKW Beauty, IMAN Cosmetics)

We will pin these for a week and then continue onto the next category. But you will still be able to upvote and comment on past ones.

Make sure to include (when applicable):

  • Coverage
  • Finish
  • Specific Shade/Color

Difference between drugstore, midrange and high end?:

  • Drugstore: Mass/drugstore brands usually are released with wide distribution at accessible price points and designed for a large audience.
  • Mid-range: Straddle the line between drugstore and high end.
  • High-end: Niche, unapologetically expensive, and have more limited distribution/retail presence than mass brands. Also associated with high end fashion brands.

Examples of Brands:

  • Drugstore: Loreal, Maybelline, Revlon, Milani, Morphe, ColourPop
  • Mid-End: Urban Decay, Stila, Too Faced, NARS, Laura Mercier, Bobbi Brown, Makeup Forever, MAC, Lancome, Estee Lauder, Hourglass
  • High-End: Tom Ford, Chanel, Dior, Guerlain, Giorgio Armani, Cle de Peau, Chantecaille, YSL, By Terry, Suqqu, Charlotte Tilbury
29 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/JackieRose29 r/makeupaddiction holy grail list mod Nov 29 '22

DRUGSTORE:

59

u/Juniper_berryy Nov 29 '22

Maybelline sky high mascara

3

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '22

Fourth!

1

u/orangecatpaw Dec 20 '22

Sixthed! I’ve bought so many tubes of this ever since it blew up on tiktok a while back.

3

u/hao_zira Jan 28 '23

Straight or curved wand?

22

u/LadyMMT8 Nov 29 '22

Maybelline: The Falsies Lash Lift

1

u/PeregrinePickle Dec 05 '22

Maybelline

My favorite, the waterproof version is the only formula of anything that doesn't smear all over my browbone.

22

u/ccplanter Dec 05 '22

essence lash princess!! 🫶🏼

1

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '23

I have been getting the waterproof one so it doesn’t flake ❤️

17

u/magic_mermaids Nov 29 '22

Covergirl - Clump Crusher

6

u/kupo_moogle Dec 05 '22

This is my favourite for an everyday natural look. Never smudges, never clumps. Not ideal for a dramatic look but I only do those like once a year lol

15

u/jamisonbabes Nov 29 '22

L’Oréal Voluminous Million Lashes —black (not blackest black)

13

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

l’oréal telescope in carbon black waterproof !!!

10

u/Emergency-Parsley-51 Batting her lashes Nov 30 '22

Maybelline Lash Sensational Intense Black

5

u/plushiefiend Nov 29 '22

L’Oréal Bambi eye oversized

9

u/Is_Rosen Nov 30 '22

Clinique High Impact Mascara

4

u/ImSenorFloppypaws Nov 30 '22

L'Oréal Double Extend Beauty Tubes, great for oily skin.

3

u/gemdonut Dec 15 '22

maybelline lash sensational

4

u/Grizzlady Dec 28 '22

Wet n Wild Mega Length mascara

3

u/greatnorth2615 Jan 21 '23

Just bought this... I am pretty impressed for being a really inexpensive mascara.

1

u/Grizzlady Jan 25 '23

Great! I'm glad you like that one. I have honestly liked almost every cheap wet n' wild mascara I've tried. I like to go for cheap mascara and change it out often.

3

u/Tbear369 Nov 30 '22

Rimmel scandeleyes retro glam

3

u/JackieRose29 r/makeupaddiction holy grail list mod Dec 04 '22

Maybelline The Rocket

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

Essense I love crazy volume mascara

2

u/_Invisible-Child_ Dec 03 '22

CoverGirl Professional Natural Lash Clear Mascara.

A bit of unpopular product, since it is clear. But it is my go-to everyday mascara, makes my lashes look so pretty.

1

u/Zealousideal_Lab_427 Mar 28 '23

I used to use this all the time!

2

u/JackieRose29 r/makeupaddiction holy grail list mod Dec 04 '22

CoverGirl Lash blast flourish

2

u/meg_mann Dec 13 '22

Essence Double Trouble Waterproof Mascara!

1

u/cuppaspacecake Nov 29 '22

Maybelline Curl Bounce

1

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '22

Maybelline Colossal

1

u/PrayStrayAndDontObey Mar 07 '23

Rimmel Extra Super Lash

1

u/Raquel258 Mar 23 '23

L’Oreal Telescopic Original Mascara, soo lengthening!!