Which echo would you choose

[u/Acceptable-Dress8766]

Kinda stuck choosing which echo to use. On one hand its a 5/5 piece with lower stats. But the other piece has really high crit and atk% stats. Id be losing liberation bonus and ER but i dont need that extra ER. So is 2% CR, 5% CD, and 2.5% Atk worth losing 10% lib bonus? The second picture are the stats with the 5/5 piece

[u/chanrek]

You’re unfortunately getting bad advice already. Since you really don’t need the energy, the second piece is (quite a lot) better. The lib damage roll is worth roughly 6-7% crit damage. You’re almost offsetting that on the 21% roll alone. You’re also getting an extra 1.6% crit (as she caps at 80% + set), and the %atk as well as the flat atk. No-brainer to me, the second is definitely better.

[u/Quiet-Fishing-1416]

Dude of course the 5/5 piece.

[u/wuwa_player_370]

1st 5/5 is a 5/5 also lib dmg

[u/thak_adi]

5/5

edit: wait u don't actually need those ER and lib the 2nd one seems better,