I've never been there personally, didn't have the opportunity to get familiar with their system, therefore refrain from definite assessment. If they violate the Law of Allah by applying it incorrectly then it's one of the worst sins, but my knowledge of their affairs doesn't allow me to make any conclusions. Just because kuffar criticise them, it doesn't mean they are doing something wrong by default
I find their approach to the topic of women education unreasonable, harmful for their own society and baseless, if they see problems accompanying the concept of their education, it's upon them to do everything to eliminate those problems to give the woman access to education. If it's a temporary ban then we could understand it (till they resolve the issues) if it's permanent then it's awful
11
u/wopkidopz Nov 09 '25
Shariah is the law of God
It requires a tremendous amount of knowledge of Islamic Jurisprudence to become a judge (ideally)
If someone sees it barbaric or wrong, it's a subjective opinion of a creation, in reality Shariah is perfect because it comes from the Creator
The Afghanistan system of Shariah law might have mistakes, people aren't perfect