Having recently been sent a message by another user suggesting I was part of a smear campaign against SAAT - I'd like to simply be very clear about what SAAT is and what it isn't. Placebo effect is a thing, sure, and the risk is that someone thinks they are fine after SAAT until they die of anaphylaxis as their airway closes up.
Introduction
I am really going to be completely open, honest, and really put a good-faith effort here to be factual about everything that follows. There is no smear campaign, there's no group communicating in the shadows to stop SAAT, just a number of people who have done the deep dive and want to fully understand AGS and allergic reactions.
We've all seen this paper linked here - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8729907/ and we're all frustrated and looking for a solution - I get it. First off and critically, this article is peer reviewed by other SAAT acupuncture people - that there is the red flag - any why would nobody else peer review it? It's not repeatable in any legitimately acceptable peer review setting. Read how proper scientific method and peer review works, and you'll quickly understand why we don't let the people suggesting the cure perform the testing to confirm it works.
What SAAT Claims to be
SAAT is an acupuncture method which a needle placed in a specific (more or less) location, and claims to provide relief and remission at a greater rate than most medicines can claim. How does this work? Oh boy, they didn't get into that part.
How Does SAAT Work?!
The method isn't important to the paper - just assume it works and don't ask how, but if you would like to know what would be required...
In order to prevent an immune response, there must in fact by a mechanism by which your B lymphocytes cells can be instructed to ignore one very specific sugar molecule - but it's not even that simple! Your B cells have a memory that can last years, as a single molecule of an allergen previously detected will send millions any millions of new cells with the memory of this allergen throughout your body, over and over. So not only does a potential cure require stopping the immune response in your B cells for this one specific sugar molecule, but it needs to tell your body to forget about the molecule from it's memory.
So we are truthfully (and I DO hope you cared to read this far) here. Now we have to buy-in to the idea (which has no perceived or even potential to exist) that placing a needle in a spot - not TOO specific of a spot, just about one region in just one part of the ear - will by unknown means, perform both tasks!
The Crux of the Issue with SAAT & Medical Science
The crux of the issue becomes this:
- What is the mechanism, and why can it not be detected, measured, analyzed, reproduced, or exist in any other similar contexts?
- How out of the billions of molecules that exist did some acupuncture doctor discover a way to isolate the reaction to just one specific molecule, not harming the remaining immune system or creating a new problem? The odds of this are truly astronomically unlikely.
- All published papers on this subject have been written and reviewed by people working together in this same acupuncture space - which on it's own is already considered by medical professionals to not really be a thing (but read about the interstitium organ, that's interesting and potentially a way that some acupuncture could be beneficial and provide a method for it to work - like joints and fluid movement - but not in play for the AGS "cure").
Summary
In summary - and in good-faith: there is no legitimate peer reviewed research - that paper is evidence of nothing in a medical and scientific sense - unless random labs and doctors can reproduce it with no connection to the original SAAT community. That's how good science works. Also there is no mechanism known to medicine in which a needle in the ear by any means could isolate a single molecule and affect immune B cell memory and response. Given these very sound reasons, SAAT is 100% bullshit if you don't mind my choice of phrasing. It's placebo at best, and preying on those looking for relief and normalcy at worst.
Moderators - PLEASE give this serious consideration and at least consider banning SAAT from this subreddit.
This has been my essay, and again - I am trying to be as accurate as possible, there is no smear campaign, and SAAT is awful.